Watching Dogs of War on A&E, with Ron and Sabot. First episode I have watched, so I don’t know if tasks are shown in different episodes.
In a lot of ways, it’s heartbreaking, because the idea of the program is that the vet, with PTSD and anxiety, is given an untrained dog, and works to get the dog public access ready. Getting a dog out enough to get the training time it needs when the handler has PTSD and is avoiding going places for fear of triggering the PTSD is really freaking hard.
When faced with going out, the idea of declaring his disability is too much for Ron, and causes a panic attack. He tries going to church (one of the few places he could legally be thrown out of), and while no one says anything or appears to notice them, Ron thinks everyone is staring at him, and he bails on his wife.
Not all disabilities do better with a public use service dog. Not all handlers are meant to owner-train. I really wonder what would have happened if Ron had been partnered with an already trained dog, who reacted to his anxiety with deep pressure, or distracted him from their very first meeting. Sabot looks to be very well behaved, but does not, as of the trip to the church, have a default task response to Ron’s stress levels. Nor did I see any sort of response once they were home.
Psychiatric service dogs need to do more than just be there. Not only is it the law that a dog do work or tasks (and being there for comfort does not count under federal law), but if the dog does nothing, it is generally useless for anxiety. By drawing attention the dog can provoke and exacerbate the psychiatric symptoms. A trained dog can be a lifesaver, no doubt in my mind, but the dog has to do more than just be there to be useful. Tasks allow dogs to be an amazing source of help. Emotional Support Animals (animals for comfort, who do not do tasks) not only don’t have public access, but are not as effective for helping a handler deal with stress and anxiety.